As Fort Monroe ends its long tenure as a military base next month, it is likely to take on new life as one of the most important historical spots in the country.
As the date for the transition approaches we are beginning to realize what an incredible position the fort and the adjoining Old Point Comfort occupies: the place where slavery in America both began and ended. That’s right, right here in Hampton Roads. And not many people realize this.
Much has been disclosed recently about how three escaped slaves sought protection at the fort and were deemed to be “contrabands of war,” and how thousands followed to Freedom Fortress, ultimately tilting the nation towards emancipation.
But what has escaped notice is the other part of this amazing story, complete with Colonial Era political intrigue.
It seems that Samuel Argall, one of the original Jamestown settlers and, at the time, governor, was part owner of a privateer, a ship that essentially had a license to steal. That ship, Treasurer, was seizing Spanish and Portuguese merchant ships and bringing the loot to Virginia to sell illegally.
Argall’s part in the get-rich scheme got him deposed and put on a fast ship to escape with his neck intact. He was replaced by one George Yeardley, he of Flowerdew Hundred – named for his wife, Temperance Flowerdew – a sprawling plantation along the James.
The Treasurer had lain in wait in the West Indies for a ship to pounce on when another privateer, the Dutch-flagged White Lion, happened upon the same waters and the two captains decided to share whatever booty they came across.
Now along comes the Portuguese slaver Sao Jao Bautista, loaded with human cargo from Luanda, a village in Angola. They capture it, grab the slaves and head for Virginia. The White Lion, with the fiercely competitive Captain John Jope (nicknamed “the Flying Dutchman”) in command, arrives at Old Point Comfort on Aug. 20, 1619 – four days ahead of the Treasurer.
Jope succeeds in trading the “20 and odd” – John Rolfe’s description – slaves for badly needed provisions. At the time, English law forbade slaves, so the arrivals were deemed to be indentured servants – even though some were indentured for life!
Guess who bought them? None other than old George Yeardley and a wealthy merchant named Abraham Piersy. Two other slaves who had received the Christian names of Antony and Isabell were acquired by William Tucker, commander at an early fort at the Point. Their son, William, is likely the first black child born in present-day Hampton – if not in America.
But the Treasurer, probably with an equal number of slaves, doesn’t finish unloading its human cargo. In fact, when the captain finds out that Argall, has fled, he quickly weighs anchor and sails to Bermuda – where he is able to dispense with the people on board.
How do we know all this?
Ever since Rolfe – the tobacco planter who married Pocahontas – observed the Africans being landed at Old Point, it’s been clear that that was the spot. But some historians have insisted that Jamestown was the actual location. Furthermore, who they were, how they got there and what became of them has been shrouded in mystery.
But recent research by California historian Engel Sluiter turned up Portuguese shipping records that tell the story in great detail – including the Point Comfort landing.
You’d think this was worthy of recognition. But so far, few Americans know about Hampton’s part in this crucial chapter in our history. All you’ll see on the Fort Monroe waterfront is a state highway marker with the sketchiest information. There should me more, a museum, perhaps, and certainly a monument. Who would not want to visit here?
That’s where Project 1619, a group headed by Calvin Pearson, the city’s former parks and recreation director, comes in. They sponsored a symposium at the American Theater in Phoebus and a ceremony commemorating the landing at Old Point last Saturday. Among the guests were several descendants of Antony and Isabell, those first arrivals. And the ancestors – at least figuratively – of every African American.
By the time of the 400th anniversary of the landing, the group plans to have a monument to the landing erected at this now lonely stretch of waterfront.
From the earliest arrivals, thousands more were brought to Virginia to labor in the tobacco fields. They gradually went, in the eyes of state lawmakers, from servants to slaves for life.
It would take several lifetimes – more than 200 years – during which, as Pearson observes, these unwilling immigrants had no legal status as citizens. “They lived here but it was not their country.” And then, finally, with tremendous courage, began throwing off their shackles.
It all happened right here.
“It was a sad beginning,” Pearson agreed, but not a sad ending.”


