It was the discovery of such photographs in history rooms of libraries, as well as richly detailed maps showing where old houses once stood, and numerous road trips through the countryside, that has led to Then & Now, Virginia Beach, a book by Amy Hayes Castleberry.
Castleberry, an interior designer, has long protested the loss of historic houses and buildings in Norfolk and Virginia Beach. Some have fallen into ruin, some have been destroyed by lightning, but many, as she puts it, have suffered “death by developer.”

It’s raining. Her windshield wipers keep time with choral music that plays softly on her car stereo as we turn onto Rose Hall Drive. At the end of the street, an elegant white house, circa 1730, once stood on 615 acres. The owners of Rose Hall were the Jacob Ellegoods, father and son, the latter a British loyalist who fled to Canada.
When the house burned down, it was replaced by an equally elegant mansion in 1820, exactly matching the footprint of the original. There was a burial plot nearby, populated by descendents of the original owners.
Castleberry founded a group called Preservation Watchdogs, who tried to save Rose Hall, and at one point they thought a purchaser had been found who would restore it or move it. But this fell through and in 2003 a developer tore the house down and replaced it with large brick houses. The only thing left are the bricks that now line a walkway at Ferry Plantation, a historic house that has survived.
We circle around on Little Lake Drive so she can point out where the burial plot was and an old tree still stands.
“It’s hard for me to come back here because it’s so disturbing,” she says.
She’s brought along old maps of Princess Anne County that are covered with handwriting that indicates where homes once stood and who owned them. There are long lost and strange names like Blackbeard’s Hill, Newsom Farms Colored Settlement and – my favorite – Starvation Hill. And lost roadway names like Pungo Ridge Road. Near the present Oceana Naval Air Station is Salisbury Plains, where a house of that name once stood until the air base arrived.
We turn off Great Neck onto Plantation Avenue. There’s a surviving gem here called Lower Wolfsnare, a gambrel-roofed house with Flemish bond brickwork that goes back to about 1720. It was originally on 6.5 acres, but now, although there’s still a brooding old magnolia tree and some fine manicured bushes, the property is surrounded by new houses and its “historic context,” as she puts it, has been lost. “You just don’t have a sense of how open it was.”
Or how interesting its history is.
Her book is organized by old and new photographs. In this case, there’s one of the old house surrounded by an open field and one of the present house that’s hemmed in by its neighbors. The caption shows Castleberry’s dogged research.
“There was a landing on the creek called Pallet’s Landing, after the family that built the house on the Jacob Hunter farm long ago. In 1651, the creek was called Oliver Van Hick’s Creek, and later it was known as Wolf Snare Creek. In the early part of the 20th century, some of the old pits used to trap wolves were still visible. The house was used as Confederate headquarters during the Civil War and was rumored to have an underground tunnel where whiskey was smuggled.”
These are only a few of about 80 old houses that made it into Amy Castleberry’s book. Some have been restored but many are gone and live only in photographs and fading memories. And now, in the pages of her book.
Amy Hayes Castleberry will have a book signing at Prince Books in Norfolk on March 13 from 1-3 p.m.
Salisbury Plains, circa 1727, survived until 1954 when it was torn down to make room for a runway at Oceana Naval Air Station. Arcadia Publishing.


