Side by side in the James River just off Newport News are the carcasses of two proud ships that once fought on opposite sides. And soon we may be able to take the measure of their gallantry from archaeological treasures they’ve yielded.
If funding can be found, the Hampton Roads Naval Museum will exhibit artifacts from the Cumberland, one of the Union ships sunk by the ironclad Virginia (formerly Merrimack); and the Florida, a notorious
Confederate raider that was dubiously rammed and sunk.
The exhibits would be centerpieces, coincidentally, of a facility that served both sides in the war, the massive powder magazine on the grounds of ancient Fort Norfolk. The Norfolk Historical Society is seeking funds to restore the magazine.
The stories of the two ships are compelling.
The sloop-of-war Cumberland, built in Boston in 1843, unluckily offered the first demonstration of the superiority of ironclad ships when the Virginia, running at full speed, buried its iron ram into the wooden ship’s starboard side. Then, as the Virginia drew back and the Cumberland slowly sank, the gunners on the doomed ship, decimated by murderous enemy fire, continued to give battle until their guns were submerged. Those who could escape dove and swam ashore, but 121 sailors could not and went to watery graves in the James.
“No ship was ever fought more gallantly,” said an admiring adversary.
The Florida was one of the most audacious Confederate ships ever afloat. Secretly built in England the same year that the Cumberland went down, the steam- and sail-powered cruiser sank or took as prizes 24 merchant vessels during one period and 13 during another, all the while running blockades to escape capture. But when the Florida put into port in Bahia, Brazil in 1864, with the captain and most of the crew ashore, a Union ship rammed her and towed the captured ship to Newport News. It was briefly an international incident, with Brazil demanding its return.
But before that could happen, a troop ferry “accidentally” collided with the Florida and sent it to the bottom. There’s no proof, but you wouldn’t be alone in suspecting that Union commanders gave the order to put the troublesome Confederate raider out of action.
Both wrecks were almost immediately visited by salvage crews who removed cannon and other valuable items. Then they were left to the whims of the rip-roaring tides that visit Hampton Roads every day. But in recent years, several things have happened. Clive Cussler, with a nod from the government, found them and brought up several artifacts. Then, in the late 1980s, watermen using clamming tongs, removed hundreds of brass fittings and parts, melting them down and converting the ingots to “CN” (Confederate Navy) belt buckles and such. The government took watermen to court, convicted them and turned the artifacts over to the Navy.
There are over 600 items in storage on the base, and a couple of weeks ago I got to experience a preview of what might eventually be on display, thanks to Naval Museum curators.
The items run the gamut of 19th century ship technology: gunlocks, bullet molds, brass screws, a sword handle, different kinds of fuses, some of them dated. A 9-inch shell for a Dahlgren cannon. A pipe with an oyster shell protruding from its bowl. A lantern lens, a sword, Light blue-green medicine, mustard, pepper bottles, an ink well.
There are anomalies like a glass souvenir from Bunker Hill, no doubt from a sailor who picked it up when the Boston-built Cumberland was in port there. There’s a shell from a Brooke gun, the type that was used on the Virginia. The only way a Brooke shell could be in the wreck of the Cumberland, you realize, was for it to be fired into the ship in the heat of battle.
And then there are leather shoe soles. They were probably worn by a sailor who gave his life for his country, one of the curators tells me. The Cumberland, like other military wrecks, is hallowed ground, a burial site for so many sailors who were present at the birth of a new and deadly type of naval warfare.
The Naval Museum has a few of the artifacts at its main facility in Nauticus, but here are hundreds more, salt-saturated witnesses to the audacious courage of sailors from both navies.
Illustration: Sinking of the Cumberland. Courtesy of the Mariners' Museum.
If funding can be found, the Hampton Roads Naval Museum will exhibit artifacts from the Cumberland, one of the Union ships sunk by the ironclad Virginia (formerly Merrimack); and the Florida, a notorious
Confederate raider that was dubiously rammed and sunk.The exhibits would be centerpieces, coincidentally, of a facility that served both sides in the war, the massive powder magazine on the grounds of ancient Fort Norfolk. The Norfolk Historical Society is seeking funds to restore the magazine.
The stories of the two ships are compelling.
The sloop-of-war Cumberland, built in Boston in 1843, unluckily offered the first demonstration of the superiority of ironclad ships when the Virginia, running at full speed, buried its iron ram into the wooden ship’s starboard side. Then, as the Virginia drew back and the Cumberland slowly sank, the gunners on the doomed ship, decimated by murderous enemy fire, continued to give battle until their guns were submerged. Those who could escape dove and swam ashore, but 121 sailors could not and went to watery graves in the James.
“No ship was ever fought more gallantly,” said an admiring adversary.
The Florida was one of the most audacious Confederate ships ever afloat. Secretly built in England the same year that the Cumberland went down, the steam- and sail-powered cruiser sank or took as prizes 24 merchant vessels during one period and 13 during another, all the while running blockades to escape capture. But when the Florida put into port in Bahia, Brazil in 1864, with the captain and most of the crew ashore, a Union ship rammed her and towed the captured ship to Newport News. It was briefly an international incident, with Brazil demanding its return.
But before that could happen, a troop ferry “accidentally” collided with the Florida and sent it to the bottom. There’s no proof, but you wouldn’t be alone in suspecting that Union commanders gave the order to put the troublesome Confederate raider out of action.
Both wrecks were almost immediately visited by salvage crews who removed cannon and other valuable items. Then they were left to the whims of the rip-roaring tides that visit Hampton Roads every day. But in recent years, several things have happened. Clive Cussler, with a nod from the government, found them and brought up several artifacts. Then, in the late 1980s, watermen using clamming tongs, removed hundreds of brass fittings and parts, melting them down and converting the ingots to “CN” (Confederate Navy) belt buckles and such. The government took watermen to court, convicted them and turned the artifacts over to the Navy.
There are over 600 items in storage on the base, and a couple of weeks ago I got to experience a preview of what might eventually be on display, thanks to Naval Museum curators.
The items run the gamut of 19th century ship technology: gunlocks, bullet molds, brass screws, a sword handle, different kinds of fuses, some of them dated. A 9-inch shell for a Dahlgren cannon. A pipe with an oyster shell protruding from its bowl. A lantern lens, a sword, Light blue-green medicine, mustard, pepper bottles, an ink well.
There are anomalies like a glass souvenir from Bunker Hill, no doubt from a sailor who picked it up when the Boston-built Cumberland was in port there. There’s a shell from a Brooke gun, the type that was used on the Virginia. The only way a Brooke shell could be in the wreck of the Cumberland, you realize, was for it to be fired into the ship in the heat of battle.
And then there are leather shoe soles. They were probably worn by a sailor who gave his life for his country, one of the curators tells me. The Cumberland, like other military wrecks, is hallowed ground, a burial site for so many sailors who were present at the birth of a new and deadly type of naval warfare.
The Naval Museum has a few of the artifacts at its main facility in Nauticus, but here are hundreds more, salt-saturated witnesses to the audacious courage of sailors from both navies.
Illustration: Sinking of the Cumberland. Courtesy of the Mariners' Museum.



