
It was many and many a year ago
In a kingdom by the sea…
So begins Edgar Allan Poe’s haunting “Annabel Lee,” which the troubled poet is said to have penned while staying at the luxurious Hygeia Hotel in Hampton. Then, shortly before his squalid death in Baltimore, he recited the mournful ode to lost love before a rapt audience on the hotel’s veranda.
The story of Poe’s connection to Old Point Comfort – he also served in the Army at Fort Monroe – was not lost on the restorers of the 80-year-old Chamberlin Hotel, successor to the Hygeia, which has recently reopened as a luxury apartment for seniors.
“Annabel Lee,” among several other of his poems, is now framed and hanging in the Edgar Allan Poe Library in the meticulously restored residence overlooking Hampton Roads.
A tour of the Chamberlin reveals many other nods to the history of that spot. And why not? Presidents Abraham Lincoln, John Tyler, Andrew Jackson, Theodore Roosevelt and Dwight Eisenhower either stayed at hotels there or gazed out over the waterscape from nearby, and their names are now associated with a variety of apartment choices.
The two-year, $54 million renovation includes black-and-white terrazzo floors, brass chandeliers and a restored 1914 Steinway piano in the hotel’s impressive grand corridor, with sweeping views of the water. One level down, in the Hygeia Health Club, a heated swimming pool, a recreation of the original, is lined with hundreds of thousands of custom-made tiles.
All the better to imagine what it was like way back when.
The first Hygeia – named for the Greek goddess of health – was built to house construction workers at Fort Monroe. It was torn down during the Civil War and replaced by a second, far grander hotel. Harrison Phoebus, a one-time Point Comfort freight agent, took it over and turned it into a posh resort for guests who came for Turkish baths and healthful “airs.”
When it fell into disrepair, the Hygeia was demolished, and that’s where John Chamberlin comes into the picture. Historian John Quarstein, who is writing a book about Old Point Comfort hotels, says he was a gambler and restaurateur who formerly ran the Senate dining room in the U.S. Capitol. A photo hints at almost a caricature of the 1900-era high roller, “rotund, with diamond shirt button, holding a champagne glass and smoking a cigar.”
Influential Washington friends helped him pull the strings to get the land and raise capital. After money delays, the Chamberlin opened in 1896. According to a new book by J. Michael Cobb and Wythe Holt, the immense hotel, with 554 rooms, offered a heated saltwater pool, a "business center” with telephone and telegraph connections and a round pavilion standing over the water “for cool, breezy summer dancing.”
By this time, there was stiff competition for tourists across the Roads at Ocean View, but Old Point had the edge on luxury hotels. At the turn of the century, Quarstein says, there were more than 2,000 hotel rooms on the Old Point-Phoebus side, with steamship lines vying for dockage. But this fledgling tourism industry suffered a blow in 1920 when John Chamberlin’s extravagant venture burned to the ground. Finally, in 1928, the new Chamberlin took its place.
The eight-story red brick hotel, long an icon of the local waterfront, was doomed by security restrictions limiting access to Fort Monroe after Sept. 11, 2001. Weathered and full of leaks, it seemed ready for the wrecking ball. Now, with the fort due to close in three years, the Chamberlin appears poised for a new era.
Sketch of the Hygeia Hotel, late 1800s. Hampton History Museum.
In a kingdom by the sea…
So begins Edgar Allan Poe’s haunting “Annabel Lee,” which the troubled poet is said to have penned while staying at the luxurious Hygeia Hotel in Hampton. Then, shortly before his squalid death in Baltimore, he recited the mournful ode to lost love before a rapt audience on the hotel’s veranda.
The story of Poe’s connection to Old Point Comfort – he also served in the Army at Fort Monroe – was not lost on the restorers of the 80-year-old Chamberlin Hotel, successor to the Hygeia, which has recently reopened as a luxury apartment for seniors.
“Annabel Lee,” among several other of his poems, is now framed and hanging in the Edgar Allan Poe Library in the meticulously restored residence overlooking Hampton Roads.
A tour of the Chamberlin reveals many other nods to the history of that spot. And why not? Presidents Abraham Lincoln, John Tyler, Andrew Jackson, Theodore Roosevelt and Dwight Eisenhower either stayed at hotels there or gazed out over the waterscape from nearby, and their names are now associated with a variety of apartment choices.
The two-year, $54 million renovation includes black-and-white terrazzo floors, brass chandeliers and a restored 1914 Steinway piano in the hotel’s impressive grand corridor, with sweeping views of the water. One level down, in the Hygeia Health Club, a heated swimming pool, a recreation of the original, is lined with hundreds of thousands of custom-made tiles.
All the better to imagine what it was like way back when.
The first Hygeia – named for the Greek goddess of health – was built to house construction workers at Fort Monroe. It was torn down during the Civil War and replaced by a second, far grander hotel. Harrison Phoebus, a one-time Point Comfort freight agent, took it over and turned it into a posh resort for guests who came for Turkish baths and healthful “airs.”
When it fell into disrepair, the Hygeia was demolished, and that’s where John Chamberlin comes into the picture. Historian John Quarstein, who is writing a book about Old Point Comfort hotels, says he was a gambler and restaurateur who formerly ran the Senate dining room in the U.S. Capitol. A photo hints at almost a caricature of the 1900-era high roller, “rotund, with diamond shirt button, holding a champagne glass and smoking a cigar.”
Influential Washington friends helped him pull the strings to get the land and raise capital. After money delays, the Chamberlin opened in 1896. According to a new book by J. Michael Cobb and Wythe Holt, the immense hotel, with 554 rooms, offered a heated saltwater pool, a "business center” with telephone and telegraph connections and a round pavilion standing over the water “for cool, breezy summer dancing.”
By this time, there was stiff competition for tourists across the Roads at Ocean View, but Old Point had the edge on luxury hotels. At the turn of the century, Quarstein says, there were more than 2,000 hotel rooms on the Old Point-Phoebus side, with steamship lines vying for dockage. But this fledgling tourism industry suffered a blow in 1920 when John Chamberlin’s extravagant venture burned to the ground. Finally, in 1928, the new Chamberlin took its place.
The eight-story red brick hotel, long an icon of the local waterfront, was doomed by security restrictions limiting access to Fort Monroe after Sept. 11, 2001. Weathered and full of leaks, it seemed ready for the wrecking ball. Now, with the fort due to close in three years, the Chamberlin appears poised for a new era.
Sketch of the Hygeia Hotel, late 1800s. Hampton History Museum.


